MesmeroWatch list, 0 saved

TV series
Poster for Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders

Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders

2025 · 1 season

A chilling, methodical cold-case deep dive that unsettles as it investigates an unsolved mass poisoning and its lingering paranoia.

Created by
Yotam Guendelman, Ari Pines
Genres
Documentary, Crime
Starring
Jeff Flock, James Lewis, Michelle Rosen
Overview
Who really laced Tylenol with cyanide? This true-crime series examines alarming theories behind the unsolved killings — and tracks down a key suspect.

Your rating is saved. See your suggestions, or find titles like this one below.

Rate it, and Mesmero finds titles that feel like it. You do not need an account.

Search YouTube for a trailer

Add to a list: Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders

You have no lists yet. Name one, and this title goes into it.

All your lists

Stream in the UK
  • Netflix
More options Data from JustWatch
Created by
Yotam Guendelman, Ari Pines
Genres
Documentary, Crime
Starring
Jeff Flock, James Lewis, Michelle Rosen
In your watch list

How it feels

Written by AI. It can be wrong.

Tone
  • darkstrength 3 of 3
  • tensestrength 2 of 3
  • melancholicstrength 2 of 3
  • eeriestrength 1 of 3
Pacing
measured, 2 of 4, from slow-burn to relentless
Attention
engaged, 3 of 4, from background-friendly to demanding
Themes
  • crime
  • mystery
  • death
  • corruption
  • grief
Places
  • big city
Era
period
Audience
adult
Form
  • true story
  • serialised
Content intensity
  • Gore mild
  • Language mild
  • Violence mild
  • Sex none
All scales, 0 to 10
Scales, 0 to 10
ScaleValue0 to 10
Action1
Horror4
Humour1
Realism9
Romance0
Tension7
Darkness8
Complexity6
Emotional weight7

More like this

Titles like Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders

TV series

Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer

2025

A somber, methodical true-crime reckoning that centers the grieving families, leaving a heavy sense of injustice and quiet dread.

Dark, tense · about crime and grief · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • crime
  • grief
  • true story
Pacing
measured
Attention
engaged
Seasons
1
Details
Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial KillerHidden from your suggestions.
TV series

Monster

2022

A grim, true-crime dramatization that lingers on the unsettling details of notorious killers and their victims.

Dark, tense · about crime and death · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • crime
  • death
  • true story
Pacing
measured
Attention
engaged
Seasons
4
Details
MonsterHidden from your suggestions.
TV series

Who Hired the Hitman?

2025

A grim, talky true-crime procedural that keeps you leaning in to untangle who was really behind the killing.

Dark, tense · about crime and mystery · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • crime
  • mystery
  • true story
Pacing
measured
Attention
engaged
Seasons
1
Details
Who Hired the Hitman?Hidden from your suggestions.
TV series

The Fox Hollow Murders: Playground of a Serial Killer

2025–2026

A somber, methodical true-crime procedural that trades thrills for the slow, unsettling work of exhuming the past and giving names back to the dead.

Dark, tense · about crime and mystery · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • crime
  • mystery
  • true story
Pacing
measured
Attention
engaged
Seasons
2
Details
The Fox Hollow Murders: Playground of a Serial KillerHidden from your suggestions.
TV series

Horses & Hangmen

2025

A grim, methodical true-crime procedural that pulls you into a quiet Danish tragedy and refuses to let go.

Dark, tense · about crime and death · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • crime
  • death
  • true story
Pacing
measured
Attention
engaged
Seasons
1
Details
Horses & HangmenHidden from your suggestions.
TV series

Butchers of L.A.

2025

A grim, methodical true-crime documentary that immerses you in 1970s Los Angeles panic and police procedure, leaving a lingering sense of unease.

Dark, tense · about crime and mystery · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • crime
  • mystery
  • true story
Pacing
measured
Attention
engaged
Seasons
1
Details
Butchers of L.A.Hidden from your suggestions.
TV series

The Jinx

2015–2024

A slow-burning, unsettling true-crime documentary that pulls you into a web of secrets, contradictions, and a chillingly banal killer.

Dark, tense · about crime · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • crime
  • true story
Pacing
slow-burn
Attention
engaged
Seasons
2
Details
The JinxHidden from your suggestions.
TV series

Unsolved Mysteries

2020–2024

A sober, unsettling hour of real-life riddles that lingers in the mind long after the credits roll.

Dark, tense · about mystery and death · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • mystery
  • death
  • true story
Pacing
measured
Attention
engaged
Seasons
3
Details
Unsolved MysteriesHidden from your suggestions.
TV series

This Is the Zodiac Speaking

2024

A somber, methodical true-crime sit that trades thrills for the quiet unease of a family still chasing an old, unresolved horror.

Dark, tense · about crime and mystery · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • crime
  • mystery
  • true story
Pacing
measured
Attention
engaged
Seasons
1
Details
This Is the Zodiac SpeakingHidden from your suggestions.
TV series

The Many Deaths of Nora Dalmasso

2025

A somber, methodical true-crime documentary that immerses you in a small-town murder and the media frenzy around it.

Dark, tense · about crime and grief · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • crime
  • grief
  • true story
Pacing
measured
Attention
engaged
Seasons
1
Details
The Many Deaths of Nora DalmassoHidden from your suggestions.
TV series

The Pet Cemetery Murders: A Ghost Story

2026

A somber, unsettling true-crime documentary that lingers on old wounds and the eerie weight of unsolved violence.

Dark, melancholic · about mystery and death · true story

Via
  • dark
  • melancholic
  • mystery
  • death
  • true story
Pacing
slow-burn
Attention
engaged
Seasons
1
Details
The Pet Cemetery Murders: A Ghost StoryHidden from your suggestions.
TV series

Homicide

2024

A sober, interview-driven true-crime series that walks through real murder cases with a tense, somber tone.

Dark, tense · about crime and mystery · true story

Via
  • dark
  • tense
  • crime
  • mystery
  • true story
Pacing
measured
Attention
engaged
Seasons
3
Details
HomicideHidden from your suggestions.

Where to watch in the UK

Stream
  • Netflix

Streaming data from JustWatch.All options on TMDB

Details

Genres
documentary, crime
Created by
Yotam Guendelman, Ari Pines
Starring
Jeff Flock, James Lewis, Michelle Rosen, Tyrone Fahner, Mary Kellerman, Richard Brzeczek, Gardiner Harris
Length
1 seasons, 3 episodes
Network
Netflix
Country
United States of America
Languages
English

TMDBIMDb