MesmeroWatch list, 0 saved

Movie
Poster for A Wisconsin Christmas Pie

A Wisconsin Christmas Pie

2025 · 85 min

A gentle, cozy holiday romance that unfolds at an unhurried pace, offering warm small-town charm and low-stakes comfort.

Directed by
John Stimpson
Genres
Romance
Starring
Katie Leclerc, Ryan Carnes, Ed Amatrudo
Overview
An ambitious pastry chef returns to her small-town roots in Door County, WI, and, over the holidays, needs to decide between her career dreams and her family’s struggling orchard business.

Your rating is saved. See your suggestions, or find titles like this one below.

Rate it, and Mesmero finds titles that feel like it. You do not need an account.

Search YouTube for a trailer

In the UKNo streaming, rental or purchase options known.
Directed by
John Stimpson
Genres
Romance
Starring
Katie Leclerc, Ryan Carnes, Ed Amatrudo
In your watch list

How it feels

Written by AI. It can be wrong.

Tone
    Pacing
    measured, 2 of 4, from slow-burn to relentless
    Attention
    easy-watch, 2 of 4, from background-friendly to demanding
    Themes
    • family
    • love
    • ambition
    • work
    • healing
    Places
    • small town
    • countryside
    • home
    Era
    contemporary
    Audience
    family
    Form
    None
    Content intensity
    • Gore none
    • Language none
    • Violence none
    • Sex mild
    All scales, 0 to 10
    Scales, 0 to 10
    ScaleValue0 to 10
    Action1
    Horror0
    Humour3
    Realism7
    Romance6
    Tension2
    Darkness1
    Complexity2
    Emotional weight4

    More like this

    Titles like A Wisconsin Christmas Pie

    Movie

    A Cape Cod Christmas

    2021

    A gentle, cozy holiday romance that feels like a warm fireside chat, with mild family friction and nostalgic charm.

    Same writer: John Stimpson · About family and love

    Also
    Same writer: John Stimpson
    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    90 min
    Details
    A Cape Cod ChristmasHidden from your suggestions.
    Movie

    Silver Bells at Christmas

    2026

    A cozy, low-stakes holiday romance that coasts on small-town charm and gentle will-they-won't-they warmth.

    About family and love

    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    84 min
    Details
    Silver Bells at ChristmasHidden from your suggestions.
    Movie

    Letters to Santa

    2023

    A cozy, gentle holiday romance that coasts on festive charm and easy warmth rather than surprises.

    Same director: John Stimpson · About family and love

    Also
    Same director: John Stimpson
    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    brisk
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    84 min
    Details
    Letters to SantaHidden from your suggestions.
    Movie

    Christmas North of Nashville

    2025

    A cozy, low-stakes holiday comfort watch that coasts on small-town charm and gentle romance rather than surprises.

    About family and love

    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    85 min
    Details
    Christmas North of NashvilleHidden from your suggestions.
    Movie

    The Picture of Christmas

    2021

    A gentle, cozy holiday romance that unfolds at an easy pace, offering familiar comforts and a warm small-town glow.

    About family and love

    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    85 min
    Details
    The Picture of ChristmasHidden from your suggestions.
    TV series

    Chesapeake Shores

    2016–2022

    A gentle, heartfelt drama that feels like a warm hug, with low stakes and plenty of family and romantic tension.

    About family and love

    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Seasons
    6
    Details
    Chesapeake ShoresHidden from your suggestions.
    Movie

    Christmas Wishes & Mistletoe Kisses

    2019

    A gentle, cozy holiday romance that unfolds at an easy pace, offering warm seasonal charm and low stakes.

    About family and love

    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    83 min
    Details
    Christmas Wishes & Mistletoe KissesHidden from your suggestions.
    Movie

    Pride, Prejudice and Mistletoe

    2018

    A cozy, low-stakes holiday romance that unfolds gently, with festive charm and mild family drama.

    About family and love

    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    83 min
    Details
    Pride, Prejudice and MistletoeHidden from your suggestions.
    Movie

    Christmas on the Vine

    2020

    A gentle, cozy holiday romance that coasts along pleasantly, offering low-stakes warmth and festive comfort without asking much of you.

    About family and love

    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    80 min
    Details
    Christmas on the VineHidden from your suggestions.
    Movie

    Love Reins at Christmas

    2026

    A gentle, cozy holiday romance that moves at an easy pace, offering comfort and quiet hope rather than surprises.

    About family and love

    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    85 min
    Details
    Love Reins at ChristmasHidden from your suggestions.
    Movie

    Christmas Wreaths and Ribbons

    2024

    A gentle, cozy holiday comfort watch with small-town warmth, light laughs and a soft romance that never asks much of you.

    About family and love

    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    83 min
    Details
    Christmas Wreaths and RibbonsHidden from your suggestions.
    Movie

    The March Sisters at Christmas

    2012

    A cozy, low-stakes holiday comfort watch full of sibling bickering, renovation mishaps and gentle romantic confusion.

    Same director: John Stimpson · About family and love

    Also
    Same director: John Stimpson
    Via
    • family
    • love
    Pacing
    measured
    Attention
    easy-watch
    Runtime
    90 min
    Details
    The March Sisters at ChristmasHidden from your suggestions.

    Where to watch in the UK

    No UK streaming, rental or purchase options are known.

    Streaming data from JustWatch.TMDB

    Details

    Genres
    romance
    Directed by
    John Stimpson
    Written by
    John Stimpson, Caroline Portu
    Starring
    Katie Leclerc, Ryan Carnes, Ed Amatrudo, Debrah Farentino, Seamus Flynn, Peter Carey, Parth Akoliya, Jennifer Joan Taylor
    Music
    Ed Grenga
    Cinematography
    Carlo Besasie
    Runtime
    85 min
    Country
    United States of America
    Languages
    English

    TMDBIMDbLetterboxdWikipediaWikidata

    Something wrong on this page? Tell us.